Culture

Postnatal aggression

Content warning: This story contains descriptions of family and domestic violence, including physical assault and harm involving children. Reader discretion is advised.

Babies are a blur.

Feeding every hour. The washing that never ends. Sleeping in bits and pieces. Your husband ignoring the screams of your four-month-old baby as he shouts at you to open the door while your free hand desperately holds it closed and the other hand grips your baby and your face stings from the slap and you’re breathing so heavily while trying to fake soothing noises for your little girl.

You shouldn’t have told him you weren’t his slave. You should have served him food when he asked. You should listen to him and open the door.

So Jules* opens the door.

Her husband punches her hard and grips her by the neck. In that moment she doesn’t know if she will die with her new baby in her arms.

Jules’ story is real, and she is far from alone. In 2019, almost one in four migrant women experienced intimate partner abuse during the first 12 months postpartum, compared with nearly one in six Australian-born women.

Experts say there has been an increase, not just in abuse, but also in the number of women seeking help. Despite increased reliance on their partners and the challenges of navigating societal and cultural expectations, some migrant women are speaking up.

The postpartum period can be a time of extreme vulnerability for many women.

Professor Linda Sweet. Photo: Supplied.

“A lot of migrants come from very paternalistic societies where the women don’t always get to make choices for themselves, as their husbands make the choices for them,” Professor Linda Sweet says.

Professor Sweet is Chair of Midwifery at Deakin University. She says domestic violence isn’t always physical.

“It could just be keeping the woman locked up at home, you know, violated in some way.”

Sara knows exactly what this means.

A mother of three and a victim-survivor of intimate partner abuse, she was a doctor in her country of origin before marrying and moving to Australia in 2013. For her, the postpartum experience was about staying alive. Trying to keep her head above the water while her husband pushed down on her shoulders. Sara was stripped of the dignity and freedom she once took for granted.

“No money was in our relationship; money was not for me. I wasn’t allowed to go outside,” she says.

Things only got worse after she had children. During Sara’s first week postpartum, a celebration was held to welcome her new baby. As guests gave money for the child, Sara watched her husband snatch every envelope, every contribution. “Give it to me, give it to me … It’s all mine,” she remembers him casually shouting.

Sara pulling out a ten dollar note from her bag. Photo: Esma Serin.

“Nine years after coming here, I saw Australian notes for the first time.”

Sara

A week after giving birth to her first child, Sara was also suffering physically. She believes she experienced postpartum haemorrhage – dangerous blood loss after giving birth – caused by remaining pieces of placenta in the uterus. When she finally got to a hospital, staff recommended a dilation and curettage, a procedure that can be used to remove tissue from the uterus.

Her husband said no.

She recalls him saying to the doctor, “no, just let us go, she doesn’t want it, just let us go.”

“I cried all my way to the home, and I remember I couldn’t even sit because of the stitches (from the birth),” she says.

Sara doesn’t know whether the memory she has of being formally diagnosed with postpartum haemorrhage is accurate, or whether the haze of pain and her own medical knowledge have shaped her recollection.

This was far from an isolated incident. After the birth of her third child, Sara fell ill and lost 25 kilograms. Unable to eat or drink, her quality of life deteriorated rapidly. She was left to self-diagnose with IBS after once again refused proper medical attention.

Manipulated into believing there was nothing wrong with her, Sara endured years of this physical and emotional abuse. Her husband started treating her like a stranger, an empty visitor in his house. For weeks and months at a time, her attempts to communicate or connect with him were met with silence.

“I got silent because of that abuse,” she says.

“Why didn’t you just leave?”

Sara says people find it difficult to understand why leaving never felt like an option for her. Despite everything she had been through, she feared the reactions of her family and community overseas. Begging and pleading with her husband not to send her back, giving him the licence to do as he pleased, knowing she would always be too scared to leave.

Communicare women’s advocate Raissa Mohamad understands this external pressure. She says culture can be a strong adhesive for migrant women, binding them tightly to their family even when a violent relationship threatens them and the children they love so much. A block on the emergency exit. Petrified at the thought of letting down their family and community, even though they are overseas. She’s had clients express how hard it is to be a single mother in Australia, prompting the thought: “no wonder women don’t leave.”

Raissa Mohamad. Photo: Esma Serin.

Mohamad works exclusively with newly arrived migrants and refugees, helping women experiencing or at risk of domestic violence. She shares the fact that it can take migrant women longer to leave abusive relationships because of the power imbalance that can intensify after childbirth.

“If he wants to take the baby from me, he will, because he’s an independent man, and I don’t have anything to offer to this baby,” she says.

Mohamad tells me some of her clients confuse women’s refuges with refugee camps, making the prospect of leaving a violent relationship even more frightening.

“Many, many times now, especially in this role, I told them, ‘I can put you in a women’s refuge’, and they’re like, ‘No, no, no, isn’t that like prison?'”

Raissa Mohamad
Fran pulling out a brochure of the program she works for. Photo: Esma Serin.

Communicare family safety advocate Fran Owode says a lot of her culturally and linguistically diverse (CaLD) clients fear child protection authorities will simply take their children away.

“As a mother, that’s a big fear, because no woman wants to lose their children.”

Owode says migrant women can face significant barriers to accessing support because they don’t know where to turn for help or how to begin leaving an abusive relationship. How can you know something you’ve never been taught?

Jules can relate. She met her now ex-husband in Perth after migrating from Kenya. He had been abusive several times before she became pregnant: slapping, punching, threating her. She says she had no idea she could seek help, let alone where to find it.

The incident described at the start took place in 2024, when Jules was four months postpartum. Her partner had demanded she serve him food. He slapped her when she told him she was too busy caring for their baby. Furious and upset, she snapped back.

“I am not your slave, so don’t do it again.”

Jules playing with a children’s toy. Photo: Esma Serin.

This led to the locked door and the punching. It was a punch that landed on the back of her neck that made her arms go limp and the baby fall to the floor. A bruise forming on the back of her neck immediately. When the shock subsided, Jules picked her baby off the floor and called the police. He was led away in handcuffs. Her husband to a cell, and herself and her baby to a hospital. Upon assessment, her baby had no significant injuries. But Jules was left with a debilitating headache.

To her horror, the court later found him not guilty.

“I don’t know how … they think I did the bruise myself,” she says softly, hesitatingly.

With the legal processes falling short of what she expected, Jules was left to rely on an 18-month violence restraining order (VRO). However, seven months later, she revoked it.

When asked why, she says she had become the talk of the community, not just in Perth but overseas. An elder urged her to remove the restraining order, while family and friends pressured her to forgive him, claiming she was ruining his life.

Jules bowed to the pressures, and the VRO was no longer in effect. He began frequenting the house again. Telling Jules, he just wants to see his baby, but soon enough shows his true colours once again. When Jules asked him to take responsibility, she says he threatened her.

“I’m going to surprise everyone.”

Feeling like she’s caught in a loop, Jules once again fears for her and her daughter’s safety.

“If someone say I’m going to surprise people, maybe one day I’m sleeping and he come and kill me, or I don’t know what he’s going to do with me,” she tells me.

This time, Jules felt like she actually knew where and who she could go to. With her baby in her arms, she finally sought refuge. She says a sense of community helped her take the leap.

Raissa reading a brochure. Photo: Esma Serin.

Mohamad says this comes as no surprise, and if years of working with CaLD women has taught her one thing, it’s that some cultural beliefs place pressure on women to stay in violent marriages and continue fulfilling the “household extraordinaire” role. Mohamad says these patriarchal, sometimes misogynistic attitudes aren’t confined to Middle Eastern or South American societies, but reflect broader societal beliefs that allow men to treat women this way.

When asked about a potential increase in domestic violence towards migrant women during the postpartum period, Mohamad confirms she has seen a rise.

“I believe society is talking more about what is a healthier relationship and what is an abusive relationship. So, because people are being educated, they are coming forward and speaking up.”

Breaking the chain

White Ribbon Australia senior program facilitator Chris Majid works with young boys, girls and men to educate them on gendered violence. His work with high school students revolves around what he calls, ‘the man box’. When prompted to write what they think it means to be a man, some answers reflect the reality of toxic masculinity.

Majid finds that belief systems like these often develop during adolescence, with some young people associating masculinity with violence.

Having worked in the prison system and with CaLD men, Majid says some beliefs about gender roles can be deeply ingrained in communities, passed down through generations.

Majid notes there is a lack of education in Australia about domestic violence and harmful gender stereotypes. He has come across migrant men who question why they haven’t learnt about gender equality and men who often don’t know where to access that information.

Chris Majid reading student responses to the man box. Photo: Esma Serin.

“I’ve learned the national anthem, and I can say g’day mate, but no one’s told me about equality,” he says.

He believes learning about autonomy, equality and respect should be a prerequisite to learn as part of a person’s journey when relocating to Australia.

Owode agrees. She believes CaLD communities need more awareness and education, and that community and faith leaders can drive this change and teach boys how to have healthy relationships with women. She tells clients who stay in abusive relationships that they are putting their children in harm’s way.

“Seeing you tolerating daddy’s behaviour, they grow up thinking it’s okay. So, you’re not raising good men by staying in that relationship.

“If you’re leaving, you’re telling your kids this behaviour is unacceptable.”

Strength, support, freedom

So, in the end, that’s exactly what Jules and Sara did.

They packed their lives into a few bags, held their children tight and walked away from the only lives they had known. Showing their children what courage looks like, showing them how to stay afloat. Small steps forward: English classes, navigating public transport, gardening and spending time together as a family that loves each other.

Doing everything they were once deprived of.

Though the memories of abuse remain, they told me their stories with smiles on their faces. No tears and no fear. Knowing they’ve done what they thought was impossible – with Sara offering these words to other victim-survivors:

“It might feel like you can’t see anything right now, but there is a way, you just have to keep going.”

Sara

Names have been changed to protect the identities of victim-survivors.

Support services

If you or someone you know is impacted by sexual assault, family or domestic violence, call 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732 or visit www.1800RESPECT.org.au

In an emergency, call 000

Women’s Domestic Violence Helpline: 1800 007 339

Concern for a child’s wellbeing: 1800 273 889. If you are calling outside of business hours, Crisis Care is available on 1800 199 008

MensLine Australia: 1300 78 99 78